you are in:
Internetnews.com >> boston.internet.com >> News
7 day summary

internet.com

Newsletter Signup

Internet Daily

Boston News

DC News

NY News

SiliconValley News

select a newsletter above, type your email and click the arrow to sign up!

Events
OWASP 11/2

Newsletter Signup
DJ 309650.94-145.86
NASDAQ1564.74-30.52
S&P 5001032.70-17.20
02:41 PM
Market data delayed a minimum of 15 minutes

get quote

internet.com
IT
Developer
Internet News
Small Business
Personal Technology
International

Search internet.com
Advertise
Corporate Info
Newsletters
Tech Jobs
E-mail Offers

Overture to Buy FAST Web Search Unit
Xerox Claim Vs. Palm Affirmed, Questioned
Ask Jeeves Bans Banners
2003: Interactive Marketing Gets in the Mix
For more stories on:
special reports
Down Yahoo's Transition Road

[ more ]
most popular
Google to Spread Social Tool Across The Web
MySpace Wins Record $230M Suit Against Spammer
Fedora 9: Linux Desktop Alive and Well at Red Hat
BlackBerry Goes Bold for Market Gold
The Big Board Goes Linux
Gates Sees Boom Ahead in Home, Business Touchscreens
Microsoft's New Math on SMB Servers
XP Service Pack Rocky for Some, OK for Others
HP Drags Down Dow
Why AMD Went the Multi-Chip Module Route
hot topics
Return of The Browser Wars
A Patent Battle on eBay Territory
SaaS in The Market
Ads And Their Influence
Sybase Whitepaper: What's New in Advantage Database Server 9? Its low per-seat cost, ease of deployment & low maintenance requirements makes it well suited for vertical market applications. Learn more.

boston.internet.com

February 27, 2003
Protecting Google Brand "Tricky Business"
By Colin C. Haley

Competing in the cut-throat Internet search sector, and prepping for a possible IPO, Google has good reason to promote itself. Privately, even rivals grudgingly concede it has done a masterful job.

In recent weeks, Google beat out Apple, Coca-Cola and Starbucks for BrandChannel.com's "brand of the year" honor and was featured in a Boston Globe Magazine cover story chronicling the use of the company's technology as a cultural phenomenon (albeit one that raises some privacy questions).

But even as the Mountain View, Calif., company's marketers celebrate its growing clout (or to use the industry's unabashedly Orwellian term, "mindshare"), its intellectual property lawyers are quietly waging a campaign to insure Google doesn't fall victim to its own success.

The effort centers on trademarks -- government protection for words or logos indicating the source or quality of a product or service. For example, Coca-Cola's trademark bars competitors from passing their beverages off as Coke. Soda-lovers know what to expect when they select the red and white logo, be it in Milwaukee or Marrakech.

But trademark law gets murky when a product or service becomes so successful it becomes "generic." When this threshold is crossed, trademark holders effectively surrender their rights. This is Google's concern. It can't afford have its name be synonymous with Internet search -- at least not in a courtroom.

Hence its note to Word Spy, an online dictionary that compiles and defines new words popping up in the media. At issue is this Word Spy entry: "google (GOO.gul) v. To search for information on the Web, particularly by using the Google search engine; to search the Web for information related to a new or potential girlfriend or boyfriend."

Google lawyers sent the site's editor a letter (portions of which were later posted to an online discussion board) saying that it wants "to make sure that when people use 'Google,' they are referring to the services our company provides and not to Internet searching in general."

Lawyers weren't as upset with the definition as they were the lack of mention of the corporate entity. Word Spy's editor modified the entry by inserting a trademark information, which satisfied Google.

Google declined comment on the practice, but confirmed that letters were mailed to Word Spy and others.

Edward Naughton, a intellectual property lawyer with the firm Holland & Knight in Boston, said Google's tack is a heavy-handed tactic but sound corporate law. The fact that Word Spy is a reference site likely factored into Google's action, Naughton added.

Judges in trademark cases use several criteria to determine if a brand has crept into the public domain. These include consulting dictionaries, surveying the term's usage in the media, and the results of consumer surveys.

"This letter was clearly sent by Google to try and convince Word Spy to take the reference out of the dictionary so there wouldn't be the foundation that it was generic," Naughton said.

The tactic then, which doesn't threaten legal action (there don't appear to be grounds for trademark violation or unfair competition suit), could accomplish two goals: eliminating, or recasting, a definition that could come back to haunt it; and making clear to the site's visitors, who could later be potential consumer survey respondents, that Google is a company not a verb.

Rulings, whether they take place in civil court or in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, have cut both ways, Naughton said. For example, aspirin, escalator, bundt cake, ice beer, light beer (or, if you prefer Miller and aren't picky about spelling, Lite) have all slipped into the public realm.

In the technology world, United Airlines lost its bid to trademark e-Ticket, and AOL was denied "You've Got Mail." As with most cases, the courts did not grant ownership because the phrases were descriptive of the service.

There have been successful defenses as well, but only by determined companies. Xerox is the most notable. The copier company has gone to great lengths, both through legal means and its own marketing campaigns, to prevent competitors from selling "xerox" or "xeroxing" machines.

"Companies begin with a new product service they almost want to have (a synonymous) association," Naughton said. "But once they achieve that recognition you have to step back, it's tricky business."


News Archives


current headlines
Breaking News
What's Microsoft's Play in Icahn-Yahoo Spat?
Yahoo, WPP in Multiyear Partnership on Ad Trading
Indictment in MySpace Hoax that Led to Suicide

Business
Stocks End Strong Week Flat
Yahoo Parries Icahn's Jab
Icahn Prepares For War With Yahoo

Developer
RIM Ups Ante With Mobile Software Push
Novell Readies Silverlight Clone for Linux
Yahoo Pitches The 'Next Generation of Search'

E-Commerce
Yahoo Parries Icahn's Jab
Small Business Has a New Online Calling Card
MySpace Wins Record $230M Suit Against Spammer

Enterprise
Greenplum Sees BI As Sweet Market
Autonomy 'Discovers' Virtualization
HP Targets Telecoms' Customer Data Needs

Government
All Talk, Little Action on 'Net Neutrality Front?
SEC Mandates XBRL on All Documents
House Democrats Try Again With Net Neutrality Bill

Hardware
Why Are AMD Systems Prone to SP3 Problems?
Gates Sees Boom Ahead in Home, Business Touchscreens
IBM's Cell Chip Moves Out From Gaming's Shadow

Networking
Enterprise Spending On Virtualization To Rise
Asterisk Going Carrier-Grade?
Apeer Has an Eye for Media Collaboration

Mobility
Microsoft Hones Mobile Search, Services Strategy
RIM Ups Ante With Mobile Software Push
BlackBerry Becomes Security Token Device

Search
Yahoo Pitches The 'Next Generation of Search'
Google's Enterprise Search Gets a Helping Hand
Is Microsoft Weaker After Failed Takeover Bid?

Security
Compliance Issues Still Bedevil IT
Debian, Ubuntu SSH Under Attack
BlackBerry Becomes Security Token Device

Software
Enterprise Spending On Virtualization To Rise
Gates Provides More Windows 7 Details
Alfresco's Latest ECM: Prying Open a Sector?

Storage
Seagate Disk Gets NSA's Security Seal of Approval
Dedupe Player Stakes Out New Domain
IBM Seeks Greater Slice of Virtual Tape Library Pie

Web Content
Is CNET The Right Fit For CBS?
CBS to Acquire CNET Networks For $1.8B
Google to Spread Social Tool Across The Web

Wireless
Apple's iPhone SDK Off to The Races
Sales Data, New Challengers Don't Bode Well For Moto
iPhone Grabs Market Share, But Not Yet in The Enterprise

xSP
IDC: Microsoft's Yahoo Deal Could be a Big Hit
Ballmer Fills in 'Software-Plus-Services' Plan
Report: Enterprise Search Will Top $1 Billion by 2010





JupiterOnlineMedia

internet.comearthweb.comDevx.commediabistro.comGraphics.com

Search:

Jupitermedia Corporation has two divisions: Jupiterimages and JupiterOnlineMedia

Jupitermedia Corporate Info


Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, & Permissions, Privacy Policy.

Advertise | Newsletters | Tech Jobs | Shopping | E-mail Offers

Solutions
Whitepapers and eBooks
Microsoft Article: Will Hyper-V Make VMware This Decade's Netscape?
Microsoft Article: 7.0, Microsoft's Lucky Version?
Microsoft Article: Hyper-V--The Killer Feature in Windows Server 2008
Avaya Article: How to Feed Data into the Avaya Event Processor
Microsoft Article: Install What You Need with Windows Server 2008
HP eBook: Putting the Green into IT
Whitepaper: HP Integrated Citrix XenServer for HP ProLiant Servers
Intel Go Parallel Portal: Interview with C++ Guru Herb Sutter, Part 1
Intel Go Parallel Portal: Interview with C++ Guru Herb Sutter, Part 2--The Future of Concurrency
Avaya Article: Setting Up a SIP A/S Development Environment
IBM Article: How Cool Is Your Data Center?
Microsoft Article: Managing Virtual Machines with Microsoft System Center
HP eBook: Storage Networking , Part 1
Microsoft Article: Solving Data Center Complexity with Microsoft System Center Configuration Manager 2007
MORE WHITEPAPERS, EBOOKS, AND ARTICLES
Webcasts
Intel Video: Are Multi-core Processors Here to Stay?
On-Demand Webcast: Five Virtualization Trends to Watch
HP Video: Page Cost Calculator
Intel Video: APIs for Parallel Programming
HP Webcast: Storage Is Changing Fast - Be Ready or Be Left Behind
Microsoft Silverlight Video: Creating Fading Controls with Expression Design and Expression Blend 2
MORE WEBCASTS, PODCASTS, AND VIDEOS
Downloads and eKits
Sun Download: Solaris 8 Migration Assistant
Sybase Download: SQL Anywhere Developer Edition
Red Gate Download: SQL Backup Pro and free DBA Best Practices eBook
Red Gate Download: SQL Compare Pro 6
Iron Speed Designer Application Generator
MORE DOWNLOADS, EKITS, AND FREE TRIALS
Tutorials and Demos
How-to-Article: Preparing for Hyper-Threading Technology and Dual Core Technology
eTouch PDF: Conquering the Tyranny of E-Mail and Word Processors
IBM Article: Collaborating in the High-Performance Workplace
HP Demo: StorageWorks EVA4400
Intel Featured Algorhythm: Intel Threading Building Blocks--The Pipeline Class
Microsoft How-to Article: Get Going with Silverlight and Windows Live
MORE TUTORIALS, DEMOS AND STEP-BY-STEP GUIDES